I dropped a truth grenade in Holyrood – and watched MSPs flee rather than face it

IT WAS A RELIEF to finally say publicly what I’ve believed for years. As I rose to deliver my maiden speech in the Scottish Parliament, I knew this was my moment. Parliamentary convention protects first speeches from interruption, and I intended to use it – because I also knew my words would land like a hand grenade in the chamber.

Several MSPs chose to walk out rather than listen. Presumably, they were too triggered by the truth. Had they stayed, they might have learned about the real devastation their obsession with trans ideology has inflicted on Scottish society.

During my campaign, I discovered these concerns are widely shared by the Scottish electorate – particularly among parents. These are the very people the left smears as “transphobes” and bigots simply for wanting to protect their children from a contested, unevidenced belief that humans can change sex.

This ideology has been aggressively pushed by the Scottish Government through its failing “Curriculum for Excellence” – a title more Orwellian than anything George himself could have dreamed up – and through guidance produced by the trans activist organisation LGBT Youth Scotland. This so-called “charity,” heavily funded by taxpayers, operates in schools and nurseries across the country. Its former CEO, James Rennie, is a convicted paedophile, and he is not the only one with such associations. One has to wonder why millions of pounds of public money continue to flow to an organisation that promotes puberty blockers designed to freeze children in a pre-pubescent state. I’ll leave readers to draw their own conclusions.

Let me be clear: my speech was not an attack on people who identify as trans. It was a direct challenge to an ideology that harms women, gay people, and, most of all, children.

Time limits prevented me from covering the damage done to the gay community. I wanted to highlight how lesbians are being told they are “sexual racists” if they exclude male-bodied people from their dating pools. Or how children treated at the disgraced Tavistock gender clinic were overwhelmingly same-sex attracted. Left alone, most would have resolved their feelings and gone on to lead normal lives. Instead, clinicians reportedly joked that at the rate they were going, there would be no gay kids left.

Despite the walkouts, I have received many messages of support from parents, grandparents, women, and MSPs in other parties. I hope we can work together on this issue, even where we disagree on other matters.

This madness will only end when enough of us find the courage to speak up and say: enough is enough.

Comments: 10

Join the debate

Do you agree with this analysis, or is the author wrong? Have your say below.

  1. Avatar
    6

    It was refreshing to see an MSP have the courage to plainly speak what we all know is the truth. Thank you Amanda.

  2. Avatar
    1

    Dear sir/madam, I have seen many children in my capacity at work, who have chosen to change genders. Usually there are underlying issues at home social or emotional and can be encouraged by mothers too but certainly schools are playing a big part. I am also concerned about the new sex education . The first minister had passed this which contained a worrying acceptance of anal licking . The diagram shows a drawing of this . An adult in the room objected to this and was removed from the room. If a 13, 14 or 15 yr old wishes to practice this then that is a personal choice but not something to be deemed as a norm . Mrs kearney

  3. Avatar
    MICHAEL BRANNAN
    1

    I have no problem with gays, lesbians etc. Their choice.
    The Trans Minority have the loudest voice in the LGBT+ and it is to the detriment of the others within the group.
    Even the gays know that a woman is not a man.
    Women are entiled to their own safe spaces and the woke nonsense from the T+ needs to be removed from all facets of life.

    1. Avatar
      Holt Linda
      Admin
      0

      I understand one was Stephen Flynn. There was also a pathetic intervention from a couple of SNP MSPs along the lines of school girls ganging up to agree they didn’t like Amanda:

      “Emma Roddick: I apologise for intervening quite so early in the minister’s speech. Does she agree that it is a shame that this very necessary debate about childcare was dragged into the space of a transphobic diatribe earlier? Does she agree that we should condemn that fully and that all children, regardless of whether they are LGBTQ or otherwise, deserve the absolute best care that we can offer and the respect of all members in the Parliament?
      Siobhian Brown: I thank the member for the intervention. I personally feel that what she refers to was not a very well-balanced reflection in this debate on childcare”

  4. Avatar
    0

    What a relief to hear common sense resides again at least in some parts of Holyrood. Thank you to Amanda for having the wit and the courage to stand up to the proponents of this harmful ideology and the playground bullies in the chamber.

  5. Avatar
    0

    This is my first perusal of the site and I agree with every word the young MSP declared I am sure I will enjoy more visits

Leave a Reply

The Reformer is funded by sponsors, member subscriptions and donations

Straight-talking Scottish politics

Get the full picture

Sharp analysis of Scottish politics, delivered weekly.